top of page

Exterior Paint? Sealer? Plywood? Oh Crap - Wish I'd Known & Followed Advice!

Oct 17, 2022
4 min read

Updated: Nov 5, 2023


Yes, I get asked this on a daily bases.

Yes, I can get to the root of your issue.

Yes, plywood is an poor surface to use.

Yes, you can use exterior paint if you'd like.

Yes, craft paint is inexpensive to use.

Yes, materials are expensive.

Yes, I have tired that with issues.

Yes, you can use sealer on exterior but...

Yes, I can help you with that problem.

Yes, we can replace and remake that one.

Yes, bad advice abounds out there.

Yes, it keeps me busy but I don't mind because I rather spend time assisting you with these problems to make having a barn quilt or painting one yourself a pleasant experience.


These are the kind of questions I get asked everyday so I will cover this here therefore I don't have to write every time these questions are asked in the group pages. Not that I mind, but it is hard to explain all in a quick post and lord hove mercy, the target on my back from some, is ridiculous but I guess envy brings that out in others. "Bless their little heart" as we'd say in the south.


EXTERIOR vs INTERIOR paint - I have learned the hard way and the pictures tell the story for me. Exterior paint fades and that is why we repaint our homes. Just a fact, Jack. The Tennessee Compass on the slide in our home town is a perfect example. It is on AC, exterior paint AND a sealer. It was once a bright Primrose Yellow, A deep purple and a medium purple. It is now faded terribly. It has been up less than 5 years and in direct sunlight. I image in 5 more years it will be totally faded and need replaced.


The image with the multi colors is also with exterior paint and less than a year, the sealer caused the paint to separate between the tape lines and start bubbling up. It also did not help that this was painted on marine grade plywood. We see how this performs in this example. It does not matter whether exterior grade, marine grade, cabinet grade plywood. It does not perform. Many types of plywood shown and various ages from 2yrs to 10 years old. All exterior paint.


Ask yourself this..."if I went to a sign company, would they sell me a sign on plywood of any kind?" No, they would not. They would offer several materials, two most popular products are MDO and Aluminum Composite (AC). So how may years have signs been made for outdoors? Years and years. A BQ is nothing more that a painted sign so why are we insistent on recreating the wheel. Why are we arguing that BQ's have only been around for so long? Let's recommend and use the products proven to work by professional. Forget the plywood. The grain will come through, the layers will separate, paint will peel and soon it will be an embarrassment to be taken down, or at least should be.


Who should I take advice from? Anyone that has over 20 years experience in the sign business or painting BQ's. We have made mistakes in our learning curve and have found products that will stand the test of time. We also can assist in save you money and time, not to mention frustration. Also, when others give advice, do they ask questions first or do they jump right in with an opinion when trying to resolve an issue.


There was a post and 30 people had given this gal advice of "what went wrong". No one asked questions and not a single person helped to uncover what the issue was. Fortunately, the right questions where asked and we got to the root of what was done wrong and her journey in BQ'ing will be a joy from here out. Yes, there a specific technique for applying the spar urethane or you will have cloudiness, bubble and bumps, caking and peeling or paint coming up. Be educated to the right products to use in this application.


So my advice, you do you. What works for you and the short cuts you want to take are your choice. However, if you want a barn quilt that will last for years to come, maybe for a family member or customer, know the facts, Jack...lol. I say that with a smile on my face.


Learn from those that have proven success and can guide you in the right direction. You know that you can have confidence in what you are creating to enjoy for years to come.


My recommendations are as follows:

AC or MDO (never plywood)

Interior Sample paint (exterior fades)

Spar Urethane Sealer (does not perform well over exterior paint)

Good Purdy Brushes (foam is junk in my opinion, hard to clean, fall apart, etc)

No frames structures (just causes rot over time and extra unnecessary weight)

Floetrol (removes brush strokes)

Frog Tape (yellow or green)

Razor Utility Knife (xacto or craft knives are a pain)

Primer (only one coat necessary - any brand is fine)

Colored pencils (avoid having to erase anything if possible)

Paper Patterns (these are a pain and a mess - grab a yard stick, anyone can draw any pattern)

Paint Saturation (learn proper painting techniques and no lift marks or uneven coats)


AND NEVER, EVER avoid asking me for help. I am always here for this!


So off my soap box and that "Karen" is still my buddy....lol


Carry on the Addiction,

Talara






12 Comments


So, if I understand correctly, you prefer indoor paint (not exterior). Do you have a preference regarding the finish (gloss, semi gloss, eggshell, matte?

Like

AC BLACK
Dec 02, 2025

if you don't recommend outdoor paint, what do you recommend?

Like

Juanita Bradley
Sep 08, 2024

Thank you so much for this. You have answered several of my questions. I appreciate how much time you put into your blog.I just joined and my eyes are hurting from reading and watching your blogs posts. Can't stop watching them. lol

Like

Toni Church
Sep 23, 2023

Talara, if i am able to find some AC around this area, what thickness should i look for? So far i have found no MDO or AC. I guess the next thing is to find a good place to order from.

Like
Talara Parrish
Talara Parrish
Sep 24, 2023
Replying to

Piedmont Plastics works with us and you can use Barn Quilt Headquarters account. It is set up as COD. They ship and we get 3mm.

Like

Marie Warda
Marie Warda
Nov 13, 2022

You mentioned using only interior paint but I thought Behr samples was exterior paint. Maybe I am just confused

Like
bottom of page